September 24, 2026 was a stacked day for PS5 horror and action fans — Silent Hill: Townfall and Control Resonant launched on the exact same date. Both scored well with critics, but they are very different games. Here is how they compare, and which one to start with.
Silent Hill: Townfall — atmosphere over action
Developed by Screen Burn (formerly No Code) and published by Konami and Annapurna Interactive, Silent Hill: Townfall is the series’ first full first-person entry, set in a foggy Scottish fishing town called Saint Amelia in 1996. It leans fully into psychological horror — exploration, environmental puzzles, and tension over combat.
Townfall settled at a Metacritic score of 80-81 after a wide sample of critic reviews, a touch behind Silent Hill 2 Remake and Silent Hill f, both of which scored in the mid-to-high 80s. Critics consistently praised its atmosphere, sound design, and setting, while combat and a lack of mechanical innovation were the most common complaints.
Control Resonant — style over combat
Remedy Entertainment’s follow-up to 2019’s Control scored higher with critics, landing around 84 on Metacritic — slightly ahead of the original game’s 82. Reviewers praised its visuals and Remedy’s trademark strangeness, with VGC awarding it a perfect score and calling it unmissable. IGN scored it 8/10 but flagged the combat as repetitive, and PlayStation Lifestyle was more mixed at 7/10, arguing it doesn’t quite live up to the original.
Platform availability
- Silent Hill: Townfall — PS5 and PC only. No Xbox release.
- Control Resonant — PS5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC, with GeForce Now cloud support at launch.
If you only own a PlayStation, this is not a factor — but it is worth knowing Control Resonant has the wider reach if you are deciding which to recommend to a friend on another platform.
Which one should you play first?
If you want slow-burn psychological horror with heavy atmosphere and minimal combat, start with Silent Hill: Townfall. If you want a stranger, more action-oriented experience with striking visuals and don’t mind some repetitive fighting, Control Resonant is the stronger overall critical performer and arguably the safer first pick for most players.
Frequently asked questions
Are Silent Hill: Townfall and Control Resonant connected?
No. They are unrelated games from different studios and publishers that simply happened to release on the same day.
Is Control Resonant a direct sequel to Control?
Yes, Control Resonant is Remedy’s official follow-up to 2019’s Control, continuing the series with a shift toward more combat-focused gameplay.
Is Silent Hill: Townfall part of the Silent Hill 2 Remake continuity?
No. Townfall is a separate story set in its own Scottish location, the third release in Konami’s ongoing Silent Hill revival after Silent Hill 2 Remake and Silent Hill f.